I was thinking about @etainclub's [Ever Steem](https://eversteem.com/) and my [Saturday Science Spotlight](/popular-stem/@remlaps/saturday-science-spotlight-natator88-on) and it occurred to me that paid voting services could harness beneficiary rewards in similar fashion in order to eliminate their clients' requirements for daily posting.

[![](https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmP2xhK78oTuccY8X6drgcvei8zYxAzG38TQSM54jXausg/image.png)](https://pixabay.com/illustrations/ai-generated-autonomous-vehicle-9055477/)

^{Pixabay license from Yamu Jay}

Instead of demanding that their clients post every day in order to receive an upvote, the voting services could direct rewards to their clients in a fully automated fashion by making use of beneficiary rewards. It might look something like this: 1. The voting service automatically posts one or more daily post(s) for organizing that day's distributions. - These top-level posts are kept at low value, to keep them off of the trending page (hopefully... I'm not really sure if that's how the trending algorithm works). 2. The voting service automatically replies to their own daily post with a separate comment for each client where the comment beneficiary is set to that client's account. 3. After five minutes, the voting service votes on the reply with the appropriate weight. Would this be an improvement for the ecosystem? ### Pros 1. It would (presumably) clear the clutter off of the trending page. 2. It would free voting service clients of the need to post daily, providing truly passive returns. ### Cons 1. The rewards that are harvested by voting services cannot be used to spur legitimate content creation. 2. The increased convenience of passive returns might lead to even more voting service adoption and less creative adoption. 3. Overvalued content is still overvalued content. ### Discussion To me, the ideal thing would be for the top-tier stakeholders to take action and protect the ecosystem against the voting service abuse that is diluting everyone's stake and destroying the value of STEEM, but it seems that this is not going to happen. So, reality sets in. The next question is what alternatives exist that would at least slow the bleeding? This suggestion might be a possible answer to that question. In the worst case, STEEM becomes a defacto proof-of-stake chain - and we're already well on our way to that situation under current voting practices. In the best case, clearing the trending page makes a place where creative authors can actually enhance the ecosystem by drawing additional value from the attention economy. Not sure whether this would be a net positive or not, but maybe it's worth thinking about(?). ### Afterthought A second option might be preferable - although it's not totally passive rewards. This would be to follow the [Ever Steem](https://eversteem.com/) method, almost exactly. Maybe an author really wants to create content that's worth reading, but they don't want to be stampeded into posting every day. For that author, the voting service could simply post a comment each day on the author's most recent post or comment, set the beneficiary to the author, and vote on that comment. If this second option is coupled with some sort of quality control, it might even bridge the voting services and the attention economy. Ultimately, it seems to me that neither of these methods should be very difficult to implement. Thoughts?

Thank you for your time and attention.

As a general rule, I up-vote comments that demonstrate "proof of reading".

Steve Palmer is an IT professional with three decades of professional experience in data communications and information systems. He holds a bachelor's degree in mathematics, a master's degree in computer science, and a master's degree in information systems and technology management. He has been awarded 3 US patents.

https://steemitimages.com/DQmWwM8dKvSHH9cqp2om3L8zU5iovAw4ZZeDvjMAc8DBwdE/image.png ---
[![image.png](https://cdn.steemitimages.com/DQmVc5QiSemwTgbZBBvWaDjzW3h3PbDhjLTcN3Vq2HeLA4K/image.png)](/promoted)
^{Pixabay license, source}

Reminder

Visit the [/promoted](/promoted) page and [#burnsteem25](/created/burnsteem25) to support the inflation-fighters who are helping to enable decentralized regulation of Steem token supply growth.